Ernie's Pizzeria Menu

Ernie's Pizzeria on Whalley Ave serves some of New Haven’s most memorable pies, blending classic and inventive flavors with a deceptively simple menu. Standouts include the savory Pepperoni Pizza and the robust Sausage and Broccoli Rabe Pie, both showcasing a perfect balance of crisp crust and vibrant, fresh toppings. For those seeking variety, the Eggplant and Spinach or the Jalapeno, Bacon, and Broccoli White Pizza offer unique, bold profiles that linger delightfully on the palate. The kitchen’s open design lets you witness dough transformation into crispy, flavorful pies, highlighting their dedication to craft. Complement your meal with a glass of Meridian Chardonnay or a cold Miller Lite to round out the experience. Loyal patrons rave about consistent quality and friendly service, creating a warm atmosphere. Eating here feels like joining a community that values passion, heritage, and impeccable pizza — truly a must-visit for both locals and newcomers craving authentic New Haven flavor.