Ernie's Pizzeria

Nestled in the heart of New Haven at 1279 Whalley Ave, Ernie’s Pizzeria offers an authentic slice of traditional pizza excellence that has won the hearts of locals and visitors alike. This pizza restaurant stands out for its vibrant, cozy atmosphere where the warm aroma of freshly baked pies blends seamlessly with the lively chatter of passionate pizza lovers. The open kitchen adds an inviting transparency, allowing diners to watch skilled hands stretch dough and layer toppings, deepening the connection to craft and tradition.

Ernie’s serves up an extraordinary variety of pizzas that celebrate both classic and adventurous flavors. From their perfectly crisp pepperoni pizza to the rich, indulgent white clam and bacon option, the menu provides something for every palate. The sausage and broccoli rabe pizza and eggplant and spinach pie highlight a dedication to bold, authentic ingredients that elevate pizza beyond the ordinary. Notably, their mozzarella with hot cherry peppers has earned rave reviews for its perfect balance of creamy cheese and spicy kick, creating a sensory experience that’s both comforting and exhilarating.

For those with dietary preferences, Ernie’s thoughtfully offers a gluten-free pizza option, ensuring no one misses out on their exquisite pies. The cheese pie and veggie pie also showcase simplicity and freshness, letting the quality of ingredients shine through. Beyond pizza, Ernie’s selection of beverages — including refreshing Miller Lite, Peroni, and an assortment of fine wines like Gabbiano Chianti — complements the rich flavors perfectly, rounding out a well-curated dining experience.

Customers consistently praise the consistency and passion behind each pizza. Longtime patron Patrick Matheis highlights the unwavering quality over two decades, while newcomer Emily I applauds the impeccable cooking and friendly, efficient waitstaff. Eric Caccavo’s encounter with the staff adds a personal touch, describing the owner’s genuine warmth and care for his guests, which transforms a meal into a memorable connection. Mike Stoll’s experience captures the irresistible pull of Ernie’s — pizzas so good you might just want to "run, don’t walk" — a deliciously apt way to describe the crave-worthy addiction these pies inspire.

What truly sets Ernie’s apart is the feeling of community and authenticity alive within its walls. Whether it’s watching the dough come to life in the open kitchen or savoring the tang of fresh native tomatoes mixed with savory sausage and peppers, every bite activates the senses with its rich, satisfying textures and flavors. Xiao Yangfan, experiencing his 143rd New Haven eatery, notes the quality and care in each pizza, paired uniquely with a classic Foxon Park soda — a thoughtful nod to local heritage.

Ernie’s Pizzeria is far more than just a place to eat; it’s a New Haven institution where craft, care, and bold flavors come together to create pizza that not only fills your stomach but warms your heart. Whether you’re a devoted local or a curious visitor, Ernie’s invites you to savor the exceptional and become part of its enduring story.

Contact: 1279 Whalley Ave, New Haven, CT 06515 | Phone: +1 203-387-3362